How To Construct a BRIC-Tracking Portfolio

I have previously written about the tremendous projected growth of the emerging markets of Brazil, Russia, India, and China (see posts from January 2007 and May 2007). Rapid economic development in each of these countries is projected for decades to come. As I mentioned back in January 2007, Goldman Sachs published a report in 2003 on the BRIC countries and projected that the economies of these countries will grow much faster than any of the current developed markets (including the U.S., Japan, Germany, the U.K., Italy, and France) and the local currencies of the BRIC countries will appreciate some 100-300% against those of the developed markets.

There are popular relatively low-cost emerging markets ETFs currently being offered, such as the iShares MSCI Emerging Markets Index Fund (symbol: EEM), which tracks the MSCI Emerging Markets Free Index. Another popular emerging markets ETF is the Vanguard Emerging Markets ETF (symbol: VWO), which tracks a slightly different emerging markets index, MSCI Emerging Markets Select Index. Both the iShares and the Vanguard ETFs are a good way to invest in emerging markets. However, both invest only around 40% of their assets in the BRIC countries.

I have been waiting for some time for a good BRIC ETF to be introduced that invests only in the BRIC countries. So far, two BRIC ETFs are trading on the market. The oldest is the Claymore BRIC ETF (symbol: EEB), which tracks the Bank of New York's BRIC Select ADR Index, as I discussed back in January 2007. The other BRIC ETF is the SPDR S&P Bric 40 ETF (symbol: BIK), which was introduced in June 2007 and tracks the S&P BRIC 40 Index.

Although I am glad that BRIC ETFs are finally available, I do not like either of the currently available BRIC ETFs. According to ETFconnect, the Claymore ETF invests in the BRIC countries according to these allocations:

• India - 13.56%
• China - 35.79%
• Brazil - 45.88%
• Russia - ???? (possibly 4.77%)

The S&P BRIC ETF invests in the BRIC countries according to these allocations:

• India - 6.70%
• China - 40.05%
• Brazil - 26.75%
• Russia - 25.05%
  

I don't like either of these BRIC ETFs because they both over-allocate investments in certain BRIC countries at the expense of other investments in other BRIC countries. For example, I fail to see the logic behind the index tracked by the Claymore ETF investing less than 5% in Russia stocks, or the index tracked by the S&P BRIC ETF investing only about 6.7% of assets in Indian stocks.

I would prefer to see a BRIC ETF that invests about 25% of assets in each of the BRIC countries. Country-specific ETFs and ETNs are available for small investors to create their own relatively low-cost BRIC-tracking portfolio. I personally would invest according to the following allocation:

• Brazil - 25% - iShares MSCI Brazil Index Fund (symbol: EWZ)
• Russia - 25% - Market Vectors TR Russia ETF (symbol: RSX)
• India - 25% - iPath MSCI India Index ETN (symbol: INP)
• China - 25% - iShares FTSE/Xinhua China 25 Index Fund (symbol: FXI)
  

In order to minimize transaction costs, I would invest via a low-cost brokerage, such as Ameritrade Izone, which only charges $5 per trade. I would also purchase a minimum of $1500-2000 of each security at the time I create the portfolio, and I would rebalance once per year. Because of the inherent volatility of emerging markets, I would probably limit a BRIC investment to 5-10% of my overall portfolio.

Barclay's Offers an Indian Stock Market ETN (Not an ETF)

A couple months ago, I wrote a post about the iPATH MSCI India Index exchange traded security (symbol: INP) that tracks an India stock market index. I indicated that this was the first India stock market Exchange Traded Fund ("ETF"). However, I have since discovered that INP is an Exchange Traded Note ("ETN"), not an ETF.

The ETN is a derivative (perhaps similar to futures) that is designed to track the MSCI India Total Return Index. ETFs typically hold shares of stock of the underlying constituents of the various indices that they are designed to follow. An ETN, on the other hand, is an issued security that the issuer promises will track the index. Accordingly, because no shares of the underlying index securities are held within the ETN, the owner of an ETN puts his or her faith in the issuer to maintain the appropriate value to track the designated index. Accordingly, the credit-worthiness of the issuer is a concern for anyone purchasing an ETN.

The Motley Fool published a gloom-and-doom article about this a few months ago. As usual, the Motley Fool's article was very superficial and did not really explain how the ETN's value is derived. I will admit that I am no expert on ETN, but I have to believe that Barclay's (the issuer of INP) hedges its risk through a combination of futures and/or options tied to the benchmark MSCI India Total Return Index.

Barclays Offers the Only Indian Stock Market ETF

I have previously written about India and how the best way to invest in the Indian stock market was through closed-end funds that invest directly in Indian stocks. India is one of the rapidly growing emerging markets and was dubbed a "BRIC" country in a widely-read 2003 Goldman Sachs report on emerging markets. In the Goldman Sachs report, Goldman projected the Indian ecomony to rapidly grow over the next 40 years at a rate far faster than the western world. The image below is from the Goldman Sach's report and illustrates the projected annual growth rates of the various BRIC countries. As one can see, India's growth rate over the next 40 years is prjected to be far stronger than that of the other BRIC countries.


Although there will undoubteld be hiccups in India's growth, the appreciation of stocks listed on its exchanges should generally correlate to the country's overall economic growth. India is an open democracy with a rapidly expanding population and is probably more politcally stable than the other BRIC countries, Russia, China, and Brazil.

I was pleased to recently discover that Barclays now offers the first Indian stock market ETF (Barclay's actually offers an ETN, not an ETF, as discussed here). Apparently this ETF went public in Deceomber 2006, but I only recently read about it. The name of the ETF is the iPATH MSCI India Index ETF (symbol: INP). It seeks to represent approximately 85% of the free-float-adjusted market capitalization of equity securities by industry group within India. As of March 31, 2007, the Index was comprised of 69 companies listed on the National Stock Exchange of India (the "NSE"). According to Barclays, the index had annual returns of 38.1% over the past five years (through April 30, 2007), 40.33% over the past three years, and 30.36% over the past year.

I am glad to see that someone is finally offering an Indian ETF. ETFs generally have much lower expense ratios than similar mutual funds or closed-end funds and are becoming more and more popular with investors. I will probably purchase some shares of INP the nest time I invest in the stock market, as this new ETF appears to be the best way for small investors to profit from the Indian stock market.

The First BRIC ETF Was Launched In September

In 2003 Goldman Sachs published a report on the top emerging markets for the next 50 years - Brazil, Russia, India, and China (collectively known as "BRIC"). In the report Goldman Sachs projected that the BRIC countries will grow much faster than any of the current developed markets (including the U.S., Japan, Germany, the U.K., Italy, and France) and the local currencies of the BRIC countries will appreciate some 100-300% against those of the developed markets.

I have been waiting for an ETF to be introduced that invests only in the BRIC countries. Unfortunately there was none until very recently. The best that a small investor could do was to purchase a broad-based emerging markets ETF such as the iShares MSCI Emerging Markets Index Fund ("EEM") that invests in the BRIC countries as well as many other countries, including South Korea and Taiwan. Alternatively, one could also invest in country-specific ETFs and closed-end funds, such as the iShares MSCI Brazil Index Fund ("EWZ"), iShares FTSE/Xinhua China 25 Index Fund ("FXI"), Templeton Russia & East European Fund ("TRF"), and Morgan Stanley India Investment Fund ("IIF").

Luckily, the first BRIC ETF has finally been introduced. During mid-September 2006, the Claymore BRIC ETF was unveiled. The Claymore BRIC ETF invests solely in the BRIC countries and tracks the Bank of New York's BRIC Select ADR Index. Unfortunately, the BRIC ETF does not invest evenly in the BRIC countries - about 48% of the assets are in Brazil, 31% in China, close to 14% in India, but just 6% in Russia. Moreover, the ETF's assets are highly concentrated among a handful of stocks - the ETF owns both common and preferred shares of the Brazilian company Petroleo Brasileiro (symbol: PBR) totaling 15.53% of the ETF's net assets.

Although I am glad to finally see a BRIC ETF, I'm going to sit on the sidelines. I don't like the uneven investment in the BRIC countries, with the investment in Brazilian companies being nearly eight times as large as the investment in Russian stocks. For the time being, I will continue to invest in EEM and the country-specific ETFs and country-specific closed-end funds I listed above.